Tha Feedback
  • Your Ad Here
    • Home
      • About Tha Feedback
      • Blogs
      • Celeb Snapshots
      • Contests
      • Interviews
      • Movies
      • New Music & Reviews
      • Podcasts
      • Videos
      •  
      • Recent Posts

        • Live Performances: Gregory Porter Sings “Be Good (Lion’s Song)” On A Subway. Enough Said.
        • Imagine Dragons Highlight The Frailty Of Humanity With “Demons”
        • What Do We Think: The Preatures Ask “Is This How You Feel?”
        • I’d RSVP For Ciara’s “Body Party” Before I’d Purchase A Concert Ticket…
        • Fantasia Turns Her Tabloid Troubles Into Tremendous Melodies On ‘Side Effects Of You’
      • Recent Comments

        • dmicole on Live Performances: Gregory Porter Sings “Be Good (Lion’s Song)” On A Subway. Enough Said.
        • Anonymous on Fantasia Hits The Trap In Her Club Clothes In “Without Me” With Kelly Rowland & Missy
        • Sheila on Fantasia Hits The Trap In Her Club Clothes In “Without Me” With Kelly Rowland & Missy
        • Kidsistah on Fantasia Turns Her Tabloid Troubles Into Tremendous Melodies On ‘Side Effects Of You’
        • sunshyne84 on I’d RSVP For Ciara’s “Body Party” Before I’d Purchase A Concert Ticket…
      • Donate!

        We want to keep the feedback coming, and you can help! Sweet Minty Jesus will pour out the blessings back into your coffers a thousand times over!
      • Subscribe to Tha Feedback

        Enter your email address:

        Delivered by FeedBurner

         Subscribe in a reader

        Add to Google Reader or Homepage

        Subscribe in Bloglines

        Add to Plusmo

        Add to My AOL

        Add to Technorati Favorites

      • Explore Tha Feedback

    • Album Review: Kelly Rowland’s “Here I Am” Is A Musical Misnomer If There Ever Was One

      Written by The IPS in New Music & Reviews on Aug 1, 11

      Kelly Rowland – Here I Am
      2 stars out of 5

      In the grand scheme of things, Kelly Rowland’s latest Here I Am is a better body of work than her other previous outings, by way of a hit single and some international exposure to actually give her a chance on the charts competing in a world full of singles-driven pop artists and R&B that has been decimated by the addition of the 4-on-the-floor Euro sound. That being said, if you zoom out and look at the big picture of Kelly’s musical output and her musical persona, Here I Am is still a pastiche of misshapen attempts and falters of dance-pop mixed with a mélange of R&B sensibilities and her internationally influenced dance successes that have inextricably woven their way into her musical DNA. Here I Am is not terrible, but we still, as listeners, walk away with the feeling that we just digested the musical equivalent of cotton candy – after it melts away, we still feel empty with a weird yet not unpleasant aftertaste.

      After 4 singles that failed to basically make an impact on the charts, hearts, and minds of all but the fiercest Kelly Rowland stans, “Motivation” landed like the Golden Ticket that Kelly needed to get her finally out of the shadow of Beyonce’ – but even then, her own success is still marred by the press and casual fan as “Motivation” settles into the psyche like a slinky sexy sexbot fueled naughty girl jam. The addition of Lil’ Wayne all but made the cliché track a pop-radio staple. Yet and still, “Motivation” pulls the wool over your eyes as nothing else on the album sounds like it and will probably not match its seemingly overnight success.

      Not to begrudge Kelly her first bonafide hit, but one wonders if the slip-shod approach of working to find a single that “stuck” didn’t hamper the flow and legitimacy of her album. Overall, there are few tracks that are really memorable outside of the album.  The semi-noticeable “Commander” is one that was somewhat enjoyable, mostly for its pounding pulse and musical directive to dance. “Keep It Between Us” is another joint that stands out due to Kelly’s plaintive yet soft and convincing soprano and the breezy backbeat. “Down For Whatever” could spin in the middle of an Ibiza dance set with a simple match of its high BPM and template vocal hook.

      Outside of those few tracks, this album feels like one big letdown. It’s not as if we aren’t rooting for Kelly – who doesn’t want to see the seemingly eternal underdog finally get some form of comeuppance? We can only hold on to hope for so long, and to be honest, there are other things one should invest it. Kelly Rowland is a beautiful chanteuse who seemingly has all the tools to be a “star”, yet she can’t seem to break that glass ceiling that seems to hold her back from worldwide domination. Is it that she has the tools but can’t comprehend how to use them? Does one blame her team? Is a wholly and complete shift to the dance world what Kelly needs?

      Instead of Here I Am being an accurate prognosticator of Kelly’s musical future, it instead serves up more questions and creates more dead ends than any of her previous works have done. In an age of divas that pop up overnight, Kelly’s longevity has been well documented, and she has the 4 videos from the failed singles during the crafting of this album to indicate that she has had numerous chances to get it right. Only time will tell if she does and if we care long enough to stick around for her, and us, to figure out who she is.

      Tweet
      TwitterFacebookGoogle ReaderStumbleUponDiggDeliciousTumblrPingAIMYahoo MessengerYahoo MailShare This!

      No related posts...yet!

      Tags:album reviews, kelly rowland

      5 Responses

      1. August 1, 2011 tlewisisdope

        I completely agree with this review except you think it’s more pleasant than I do. I think it’s banality is infuriating in the extreme. But I admit to not really liking the sonic bedrock that make up much of this historical moment in black pop, so there is a bias against this trendy pop swill she has released.

        As I mentioned before, at this point I do not think Kelly Rowland has anything that she wants to offer the world. I don’t think she goes into any project with a burning desire to share a thought, or a feeling, or a perspective. I don’t think she has any sense of what she sounds best singing. I don’t think she has any clear sense of which producers and writers in the game would be fun to work with. I don’t even think she has any sense of how to experiment or play.

        And I don’t think there is anyone around her to help. I keep thinking of Janet Jackson’s first albums. How pedestrian and ineffectual they are. And then along come Jimmy Jam and Terry Lewis who help Janet find her voice.

        This is what Kelly Rowland needs. She needs collaborators who can help her dig into herself, who understand her limitations, and who genuinely see something great in her. That last point is critical. I don’t think anyone around her – despite all the fabulous talking points – has any faith in her whatsoever.

      2. August 1, 2011 The IPS

        Collaborator. Definitely. She is nickel and diming her way into albums and it is SO obvious with all this disparate music.

      3. August 1, 2011 Nikki Dai

        I hope she finds one because I’m tired of her act.

      4. August 1, 2011 whateva

        I was really disappointed to listen to this album and find that Motivation was the only song I like on the CD. I was really rooting for her. What I find sad is that when I listen to any of Beyonce’s albums her songs are really not any better by any great margin, yet she has undeniably solidified herself a space in pop history … I creadit that to her confidence and pretty much sticking with a formula that works for her. I think Thewisisdope is correct, Kelly doesn’t have any direction. She is just winding her way through this career hoping to happen upon her niche … which I think she kinda did with Motivation.

      5. August 2, 2011 KBJr.

        While I agree with you overall, I wasn’t as displeased. Here’s my review (we’re often on the same wavelength IPS):

        http://wisesenator.blogspot.com/2011/07/reviewing-kelly-rowlands-here-i-stand.html

      RSS feed for comments on this post.

      Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

      • Tweets Is Watchin’

      • On Facebook?

        Tha Feedback

        Promote Your Page Too
      • Tha Feedback!

        Welcome to Tha Feedback, where we give you our $.02 whether you want it or not! Featuring celebrity gossip, reviews, photos, interviews, and more, Tha Feedback gives you the content you want with the 100% unadulterated honesty you need.


        Tips? Funny stories? Ideas? Pictures? Videos? Hit us up!


        i n f o @ t h a f e e d b a c k . c o m


        Leave a nickname so that we can credit you!


        Check out our new forum & message board!! Discuss, meet, share & more here!


        Check out our Myspace page! myspace.com/thafeedback


        Alltop, all the top stories

      • Your Ad Here
      • Send Us Your Music!

        Send me your track
    •  
      • Latest Album Reviews

        Fantasia Turns Her Tabloid Troubles Into Tremendous Melodies On ‘Side Effects Of You’
        • Fantasia Turns Her Tabloid Troubles Into Tremendous Melodies On ‘Side Effects Of You’
        Album Review: Brandy’s “Two Eleven” Is A Work Fitting For An R&B Veteran And Diva
        • Album Review: Brandy’s “Two Eleven” Is A Work Fitting For An R&B Veteran And Diva
        Album Reviews: Monica’s “New Life” Isn’t Anything We Haven’t Musically Experienced Before
        • Album Reviews: Monica’s “New Life” Isn’t Anything We Haven’t Musically Experienced Before
        • Things You Should Ch-Ch-Check Out: Waajeed x DJ Topspin, Nancy Wilson & Robert Glasper
        Betty Wright Schools You On “The Game” & Proves Why She’s Still Valid With Latest Release
        • Betty Wright Schools You On “The Game” & Proves Why She’s Still Valid With Latest Release
        Album Review: Kelly Rowland’s “Here I Am” Is A Musical Misnomer If There Ever Was One
        • Album Review: Kelly Rowland’s “Here I Am” Is A Musical Misnomer If There Ever Was One
        Album Review: Beyoncé Keeps It Surprisingly Simple On “4″
        • Album Review: Beyoncé Keeps It Surprisingly Simple On “4″
        Album Review: It’s A New Day And Jill Scott Is Letting “The Light Of The Sun” Shine Through
        • Album Review: It’s A New Day And Jill Scott Is Letting “The Light Of The Sun” Shine Through
        Explore Music: Támar Davis Has Arrived And The Sista Is Doing It For Herself
        • Explore Music: Támar Davis Has Arrived And The Sista Is Doing It For Herself
        Album Review: Jennifer Hudson’s “I Remember Me” Feels Like An Afterthought
        • Album Review: Jennifer Hudson’s “I Remember Me” Feels Like An Afterthought
        Album Review: Diddy-Dirty Money’s “Last Train To Paris” Is Overcapacity By One — Diddy
        • Album Review: Diddy-Dirty Money’s “Last Train To Paris” Is Overcapacity By One — Diddy
        Album Review: Kanye West Gives Us A $9.99 Peek Into His “Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy”
        • Album Review: Kanye West Gives Us A $9.99 Peek Into His “Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy”
        Album Review: Jazmine Sullivan Commands Respect With “Love Me Back”
        • Album Review: Jazmine Sullivan Commands Respect With “Love Me Back”
        Album Review: Ne-Yo’s Libra Scale Needs To Be Zeroed Out & Re-calibrated
        • Album Review: Ne-Yo’s Libra Scale Needs To Be Zeroed Out & Re-calibrated
        Album Review: “Something About Faith” Sounds Tenuous But Strong On New Album
        • Album Review: “Something About Faith” Sounds Tenuous But Strong On New Album
        Mixtapes: B. Slade’s (AKA Tonex’) “A Brilliant Catastrophe” Is Musically Creative And Lyrically Potent
        • Mixtapes: B. Slade’s (AKA Tonex’) “A Brilliant Catastrophe” Is Musically Creative And Lyrically Potent
        Album Review: Fantasia’s “Back To Me” Is A Soulful Yet Glossy Musical Experience
        • Album Review: Fantasia’s “Back To Me” Is A Soulful Yet Glossy Musical Experience
        • Album Review: Janelle Monáe’s “The ArchAndroid” Is A Futuristic-Rock-Soul-Funk-Opera-Musical
        • All Drinks Are On Jaheim For “Another Round” On Latest Album
        Let Nneka Help You Escape Your “Concrete Jungle”
        • Let Nneka Help You Escape Your “Concrete Jungle”
        Sade Matures & Yet Retains Their Signature Sound On Their Latest Project
        • Sade Matures & Yet Retains Their Signature Sound On Their Latest Project
        • B.o.B. Drops May 25th, His Latest & Greatest Mixtape For The Masses
        • Aaron Sledge’s Self-Titled Gospel Debut Fails To Impress
        Free Music Friday; The FreEP Edition — Tha Boogie, Young Nate & Lloyd
        • Free Music Friday; The FreEP Edition — Tha Boogie, Young Nate & Lloyd
        Res Proves That Black.Girls.Rock On New [Free!] Album
        • Res Proves That Black.Girls.Rock On New [Free!] Album
        Omarion’s Living In His Illusions With New Album Ollusion
        • Omarion’s Living In His Illusions With New Album Ollusion
        • Susan Boyle Never “Dreamed” She’d Be This Successful!
        • Album Review: Mary J. Blige Trades Soul For Sheen on “Stronger With Each Tear”
        • Album Review: Shakira Howls In Spanish & English on “She Wolf”
        • Behind Alicia Keys’ “The Element of Freedom”, Track By Track
        • The Doctor, Robin Thicke, Is In With “Sex Therapy: The Session”
        • Kid Sister Makes It Fun Again For A Minute On “Ultraviolet”
        • Amerie’s Not Fighting The Past Too Fiercely On “In Love & War”
        • Wale May Have An “Attention Deficit” Problem, But He Has Our Full Attention
        • Album Review: Fashawn’s “Boy Meets World”
        • Album Reviews: Adrianne Archie – “Heart Soul Mind & Strength” (Gospel)
        • Album Review: Ghostface Killah – “Ghostdini: Wizard Of Poetry In Emerald City”
        • The Reviews Are In: Mario, N’Dambi & All-4-One
        • Album Review: Mariah Carey’s “Memoirs of An Imperfect Angel”
        • Album Review: Muse’s “The Resistance”
        • Album Review: Trey Songz’ “Ready” (via Twitter)
        • Album Review: Jordin Sparks – “Battlefield”
        Album Reviews: The-Dream’s “Love Vs. Money”
        • Album Reviews: The-Dream’s “Love Vs. Money”
        Album Review: Ryan Leslie – “Ryan Leslie”
        • Album Review: Ryan Leslie – “Ryan Leslie”
        • Tha Feedback’s Cops & Bothers — CD Reviews
        • Album Review: Jazmine Sullivan’s “Fearless”
        • Album Review: Jennifer Hudson’s Debut Album
        • The Gentlemen of R&B: Quick Reviews of the Latest Albums
        • New Music: Danity Kane – “Make Me Sick” // “Welcome to the Dollhouse” Review
      • Tags

        album covers album reviews beyonce chris brown classic flashback coverage diddy explore music fail get that check girl stop hip-hop hip hop is dead i can't i like it! international jennifer hudson kanye west keri hilson live performances LOL magazine covers mariah carey mary j. blige michael jackson mixtapes movie news music news music videos new artists new music nignorant old school random videos reality tv really? rihanna sat down The IPS blogs trailers tv usher what do we think? whitney houston WTF!
      • Blogroll

        • A Black Girl’s Guide To Sex and Seduction
        • Alltop
        • Black Blog Media Community
        • Black Diamond
        • BlogXilla
        • Crunk & Disorderly
        • DC to BC
        • Fly Style Life
        • Gossip On This
        • Gyant Unplugged
        • Hip Hop Universe
        • I Am Domo
        • I Love Brandy
        • J. Dakar
        • Let Me Upgrade You
        • Mandom
        • Merc80.com
        • Minority Weirdos
        • Mirth:Nadir
        • Moe Arora
        • My Urban Glamour
        • MzVirgo
        • Necole Bitchie
        • nOvaSlim.com
        • On221
        • Pop Culture Fix (Formerly Pop Culture Junkie)
        • Real Recognizes Real
        • Repping Beantown
        • RNB Music And Gossip
        • Savvy Fatty
        • SoulBounce
        • Sparkle Sayz
        • STR8NYC
        • Straight From The “A”
        • SwaggInc.com
        • Tha Hot Seat
        • That Grape Juice
        • That’s Not Hott!!
        • The Beatniks
        • The Concrete Journal
        • The Conduit Magazine
        • The Fury
        • The Lil’ Creole Pimp Chronicles
        • The Red Report
        • Urban Newz
        • Urbanfix
        • Wifee’s World
        • Wooden Nickels
        • Word Izz
    •  
    • About Tha Feedback
    • Blogs
    • Celeb Snapshots
    • Contests
    • Interviews
    • Movies
    • New Music & Reviews
    • Podcasts
    • Videos
    •  
    Page 1 of 11
  • Your Ad Here

  • © 2009 Tha Feedback // Sweet Minty Jesus Approved ©
    ZILLZDESIGNEDIT